| Pumpkin 2012 |
| Contestant | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Omar Elkhader | 3 25 |
4 25 |
2 28 |
| 5 Diedra Gatzke | 2 25 |
2 27 |
3 26 |
| 5 Desmond Hanan | 2 26 |
1 28 |
1 28 |
| 5 Isaac Schaal | 1 28 |
3 26 |
1 28 |
| 5 John Glanzer | 4 23 |
2 27 |
3 27 |
| 17 Michael Hauschildt | 4 21 |
4 25 |
4 25 |
| 19 Michael Keogan | 3 23 |
1 28 |
4 26 |
| 19 Connor DeJong | 1 26 |
3 26 |
2 27 |