| Pumpkin 2012 |
| Contestant | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Kyle Anderson | 4 27 |
3 27 |
1 27 |
| 1 Kayla Krueger | 2 28 |
3 28 |
3 27 |
| 3 Alexandra Mattern | 4 25 |
4 26 |
5 27 |
| 3 Whitney Rosebrock | 5 26 |
5 25 |
4 25 |
| 3 Amanda Oeffner | 5 24 |
4 20 |
5 26 |
| 4 Megan Swets | 2 27 |
3 27 |
3 26 |
| 4 Summer Rogers | 1 30 |
4 26 |
1 27 |
| 4 Sean Hicks | 4 24 |
3 24 |
5 24 |
| 5 Blanche Froelich | 3 29 |
1 30 |
2 29 |
| 7 Tessa Petersen | 3 25 |
5 17 |
3 28 |
| 8 Zeljka Blagojevic | 2 29 |
2 29 |
4 29 |
| 8 Divine Zheng | 1 29 |
3 27 |
1 30 |
| 8 Jordan Schmidt | 1 30 |
3 28 |
2 29 |
| 8 James Tipton | 2 29 |
1 27 |
4 24 |
| 8 Judah Wagner | 1 28 |
2 29 |
3 27 |
| 9 Amy Shan | 1 30 |
4 19 |
3 29 |
| 9 Hanna Jorgensen | 4 27 |
5 19 |
5 23 |
| 9 Edwin Iraheta | 5 21 |
4 26 |
4 27 |
| 10 Emily Pillatzki | 4 28 |
2 28 |
4 23 |
| 12 Haley Maxwell | 1 30 |
2 28 |
1 29 |
| 12 Aimee Bannwarth | 2 30 |
1 30 |
1 30 |
| 12 Anna Perry | 3 28 |
1 30 |
2 30 |
| 13 Kayla Schwartz | 3 27 |
2 25 |
2 26 |
| 16 Molly Townsend | 4 25 |
2 29 |
2 28 |
| 17 Kailyn Johnson | 3 26 |
4 26 |
2 25 |
| 17 Ally Stowe | 3 28 |
1 29 |
4 26 |
| 19 Shelby Kluver | 2 28 |
1 29 |
3 24 |
| 21 Carolyn Groves | 5 27 |
5 24 |
5 23 |
| 22 Elsie West | 5 26 |
5 26 |
1 30 |
| 23 Morgan Hammann | 5 23 |
5 25 |
5 22 |