| Pumpkin 2012 |
| Contestant | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Stefanie Plummer | 5 27 |
4 26 |
3 26 |
| 1 Kallie Marske | 1 29 |
3 28 |
4 27 |
| 3 Bailey Dix | 1 23 |
5 24 |
5 25 |
| 3 Alexandra Mattern | 2 28 |
2 29 |
3 28 |
| 4 Bailey Quanbeck | 1 30 |
1 29 |
1 30 |
| 4 Natalie Osheim | 4 24 |
5 25 |
5 24 |
| 4 Josh Mikeworth | 3 27 |
1 29 |
2 29 |
| 4 Sheila Coyle | 4 20 |
4 26 |
5 27 |
| 4 Troy Small | 5 25 |
5 25 |
4 26 |
| 5 Desmond Hanan | 4 27 |
5 23 |
3 28 |
| 5 Josh Sorbe | 3 27 |
3 27 |
4 26 |
| 5 Peyton Powers | 4 27 |
3 28 |
2 28 |
| 7 Abi Bitter | 5 23 |
2 28 |
4 26 |
| 7 Jessie Koob | 4 28 |
3 28 |
2 29 |
| 7 Brittany Moldstad | 2 22 |
3 26 |
4 27 |
| 8 Trevin Harmacek | 2 28 |
2 28 |
4 25 |
| 8 Brittany Helm | 2 29 |
3 28 |
1 30 |
| 8 Jason Williamson | 1 30 |
5 25 |
2 28 |
| 9 Jaden Stout | 5 24 |
1 30 |
1 28 |
| 10 Emily Pillatzki | 5 26 |
3 27 |
5 24 |
| 10 Rebekah Tuchscherer | 3 28 |
2 29 |
5 24 |
| 12 Bailey Larson | 1 28 |
2 28 |
1 30 |
| 12 Samuel Maxwell | 1 30 |
2 27 |
1 30 |
| 12 Shreya Chandran | 1 29 |
1 29 |
1 29 |
| 12 Cody Bloomer | 2 29 |
5 28 |
3 26 |
| 12 Kady Harris | 5 25 |
5 24 |
3 28 |
| 12 Shaylee Wilcox | 2 28 |
1 30 |
2 29 |
| 12 Cecily Fogarty | 5 18 |
2 29 |
3 27 |
| 13 Erin Bechtel | 4 27 |
4 28 |
5 26 |
| 13 Monica Boyer | 3 28 |
2 29 |
1 30 |
| 13 Maisy Kleinschmit | 5 26 |
5 25 |
4 27 |
| 16 Haylee DeVaney | 2 26 |
4 26 |
2 28 |
| 17 Kailyn Johnson | 1 28 |
1 29 |
2 29 |
| 17 Rosa Fernandez | 3 21 |
3 27 |
2 27 |
| 17 Elizabeth Ferdinand | 3 29 |
1 29 |
3 27 |
| 17 Dan Zimmerman | 3 27 |
1 28 |
1 29 |
| 17 Miliyna Megosha | 2 29 |
4 26 |
5 26 |
| 20 Darcy Mogler | 5 26 |
4 27 |
5 26 |
| 21 Randi Stuart | 4 26 |
5 25 |
5 23 |
| 22 Cassa Kuhl | 5 28 |
4 25 |
3 27 |
| 23 Jordan Hulscher | 3 25 |
5 25 |
4 28 |
| 23 Shannon Meyer | 4 26 |
4 26 |
5 20 |