| Pumpkin 2012 |
| Contestant | Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3 Kalen Day | 5 21 |
5 26 |
4 27 |
| 3 Jessica Mitzel | 5 25 |
2 29 |
4 25 |
| 4 Hanna Foley | 5 26 |
3 28 |
2 29 |
| 4 Bailey Quanbeck | 1 29 |
2 30 |
4 27 |
| 4 Natalie Osheim | 5 24 |
3 27 |
5 27 |
| 4 Allison Poncelet | 5 25 |
5 27 |
5 22 |
| 5 Blanche Froelich | 4 26 |
3 29 |
2 30 |
| 6 Camie Hudson | 3 27 |
5 26 |
5 23 |
| 6 Kendall Zubke | 5 24 |
5 26 |
5 27 |
| 7 Lizzie Angerhofer | 5 22 |
3 27 |
3 28 |
| 8 Gabbie Ammann | 2 29 |
4 27 |
5 26 |
| 8 Madison Dalen | 2 29 |
2 29 |
1 30 |
| 8 Robbie DiGuilio | 1 30 |
2 28 |
2 29 |
| 8 Joe Hiatt | 1 30 |
4 27 |
1 30 |
| 8 Emelia O'Toole | 2 27 |
5 26 |
3 28 |
| 8 Whitney Ponwith | 4 24 |
1 29 |
2 29 |
| 8 Nancy Vo | 3 28 |
2 28 |
2 28 |
| 9 Edwin Iraheta | 4 26 |
5 24 |
4 27 |
| 9 Jaden Stout | 3 27 |
4 28 |
3 28 |
| 10 Rebecca Schrupp | 3 28 |
3 28 |
3 28 |
| 12 Margaret Dow | 2 30 |
3 27 |
4 25 |
| 12 Meghan Kunkel | 2 28 |
1 30 |
1 30 |
| 12 Shelby Bloomer | 1 30 |
1 30 |
1 30 |
| 12 Bailey Larson | 2 30 |
1 30 |
1 29 |
| 12 Mattie Penisten | 1 30 |
1 30 |
1 30 |
| 12 Clara Bentz | 3 28 |
1 29 |
3 30 |
| 12 Abigail Timmerman | 4 25 |
5 25 |
5 25 |
| 13 Malia Lukomski | 4 27 |
4 27 |
5 26 |
| 13 Daphney Miller | 1 29 |
4 27 |
3 28 |
| 13 Logan Lanz (drop) | N/S | N/S | N/S |
| 15 Breanna Habeck | 5 25 |
5 26 |
5 24 |
| 17 Alex Schumacher | 5 26 |
2 28 |
4 27 |
| 19 Ashley Brage | 3 25 |
5 27 |
2 30 |
| 21 Ian Austin | 5 23 |
5 25 |
5 26 |
| 22 Brittany Kuhl | 4 26 |
4 26 |
5 26 |